The Pain Game: How Much Can You take?

MrTopStep

THE OPENING PRINT

Our view.

// OUR VIEW

—

Stacked Deck And The PitBull’s Thursday Low

First of all, I am speechless. The ES rally from Wednesday’s lows was the good part. The bad parts were the big gap-up opening that gave way to selling and the Fed signaling higher interest rates ahead. Add to that Trump’s miserable showing at the trilateral meeting and what I believe may have added to the selling pressure in NVDA and AMD: investors selling other stock positions to raise cash for Anthropic’s IPO. Last but not least, investors are increasingly questioning whether the hundreds of billions of dollars being poured into AI chips, data centers, and infrastructure will ever generate sufficient returns. Put it all together, and it’s no wonder the markets got hammered.

I am not going to do a big OP today. I just got back from a hellish ride to Miami after being interviewed by Riz from the trader YouTube channel Words of Rizdom. I was honored to tell my story and to be part of the long history of the markets, and Riz could not have been a better guy.

Join us Live for Part 2 with the Queen of Fibs.

Carolyn Boroden: Queen of Fibs Returns, Friday Nov. 20 at 2 p.m. ET, live in the Pit and ANCHORS.

Join us live in the ANCHORS Room. It’s free. Join here.

// OUR LEAN

—

// GUEST POST

—

What Followed Down Novembers

Rich Miller | HandelStats

Including this month’s unfinished reading, 40 Novembers have been up and 17 have been down since 1970. After the 16 prior completed down Novembers, December finished higher 14 times and lower twice, an 87.5% up rate.

The closest historical comparison to where we stand today is a down November that still leaves $SPX up for the year. That happened eight times, and December finished higher in seven of those eight years, also 87.5%.

November is still in progress. If $SPX closes the month lower and remains above its 2025 close, 2026 will be the ninth year to fit that setup.

All figures reflect S&P 500 price changes and exclude dividends.

Rich Miller is a former Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) floor trader with over 40 years of experience in the futures markets. He is the founder of HandelStats, a quantitative research service providing statistically derived levels based on options pricing, volatility, and time-based market structure.

// MARKET RECAP

—

November 19, 2026 ES futures session statistics

December ES opened Wednesday night at 7340.50, right at the prior settlement. It put in its overnight low at 7338.25 in the opening five minutes, then rallied to 7440.50 in the 6:55 a.m. ET bar. Some of that bid had already come out by the bell, but Globex still finished at 7411.25, up 70.75 points from Wednesday’s settlement.

The regular session opened at 7411.00 and got to 7436.50 in the first five minutes. That was the cash-session high. The gap gave way, and the 3:05 p.m. bar traded down to 7192.00. ES was at 7213.25 at 3:50 p.m. and finished the regular session at 7194.25. Selling carried into the cleanup, where the 4:45 p.m. bar made the full-session low at 7167.75.

ES officially settled at 7197.25 and last traded at 7182.50, 158 points below Wednesday’s settlement, on about 2.48 million contracts. December NQ made its high at 27838.00 in the 9:50 a.m. bar, closed regular trading at 26588.25, and officially settled at 26600.25. It last traded at 26505.50, with just under 988,000 contracts for the session. The overnight rally gave sellers plenty of room once the cash-session highs failed.

// MOC

—

A $5.4 Billion Buy Reveal Gives Way to a Sell Close

The Reveal for the MOC on November 19 was $5.4 billion to buy. Buy orders totaled $7.30 billion against $1.90 billion to sell. By 3:55 p.m. the buy imbalance had narrowed to $1.84 billion as buy dollars fell and sell dollars grew. The 3:55 p.m. period through the close is usually discretionary traders closing out the day. This time the balance swung to $399 million to sell, recovered to $891 million to buy by 3:58, then finished at $426 million to sell.

Apple led the Reveal buyers at $478 million, followed by Micron at $416 million and AMD at $369 million. Those three alone accounted for more than $1.26 billion of buy imbalance. McDonald’s led the sellers at $71 million. There were sellers inside technology too, including Seagate at $58 million and Microsoft at $54 million.

Technology accounted for $2.47 billion of the Reveal’s net buying, with 71% of its symbols on the buy side. Health care added $669 million despite Eli Lilly appearing among the largest sellers. Utilities showed how dollars and breadth can part ways. The sector had $80 million to buy even though a majority of its names leaned sell.

The first read favored buyers on both size and breadth. What stands out is how little buying survived the last minute. Gross buys fell from $2.82 billion to $850 million. Sell dollars also fell, but enough remained to leave sellers with the final imbalance.

Want to follow the auction pressure behind this recap? Explore the MIM’s live imbalance snapshots and sector view.

// PIT TRADING ROOM

—

Don’t trade the open alone. Join us live in The Pit for free, follow the conversation, and bring your questions.

Rich Miller of HandelStats in The Pit

Rich Miller of HandelStats is the scheduled Friday host. Start time pending verification.

// LEVELS

—

// CALENDAR

—

Economic Calendar

U.S. Economic Calendar for November 20, 2026

Earnings Calendar

S&P 500 Earnings Calendar for November 20, 2026

// BREADTH DATA

—

DAILY BREADTH · November 19, 2026
MeasureValue
NYSE Breadth14% Upside Volume
Nasdaq Breadth34% Upside Volume
Total Breadth27% Upside Volume
NYSE Advance/Decline18% Advance
Nasdaq Advance/Decline23% Advance
Total Advance/Decline21% Advance
NYSE New Highs/New Lows10 / 423
Nasdaq New Highs/New Lows58 / 802
NYSE TRIN1.32 (reported)
Nasdaq TRIN0.56 (reported)

Completed U.S. cash session; reported closing TRIN when available. Source: WSJ Markets Diary. Feed: Thursday, November 19, 2026.

WEEKLY BREADTH · WEEK ENDING · November 13, 2026
MeasureValue
NYSE Breadth51% Upside Volume
Nasdaq Breadth55% Upside Volume
Total Breadth53% Upside Volume
NYSE Advance/Decline52% Advance
Nasdaq Advance/Decline54% Advance
Total Advance/Decline53% Advance
NYSE New Highs/New Lows128 / 419
Nasdaq New Highs/New Lows291 / 801
NYSE TRIN1.04 (calculated)
Nasdaq TRIN0.96 (calculated)

WSJ Weekly Totals; TRIN calculated from weekly issues and volume. Highs/lows are not unique-name counts. Source: WSJ Markets Diary. Feed: Friday, November 13, 2026.

// IN OUR TRADING ROOMS

—

Polaris Trading Group

Polaris Trading Group’s Thursday, November 19 session started with an early long lean, then shifted to watching whether any support could hold as volatility expanded. David tracked 7375 as his line in the sand and 7320 as a put-wall zone. The room saw a brief stretch of two-way trade around that lower area before a much sharper leg down took over near midday.

The opening lean and the 7375 pivot

  • David maintained his early long lean just after the cash open. By about 10:17 a.m. ET, he flagged price coming back to 7375. That was the line he was watching as the opening strength came under pressure.

  • The opening pace drew different responses in the room. One member preferred to sit out the first 30 minutes as a standing rule. Another described a reversal setup they found acceptable and chose to stop trading for the day afterward.

  • By about 10:33 a.m., the focus had moved to 7320. David identified it as the put wall, while room discussion turned to whether another test would hold or break through.

Two-way trade at 7320

  • David reported one-minute average true range at 10.50 points around 10:48 a.m. By 11:12, he said ATR had eased from roughly 11 to 8 as trade began balancing in both directions.

  • At about 11:21, he said the 7320 zone was reacting as expected and described the action as consolidation. The softer ATR reading and the two-way trade gave the room a brief pause after the first downside push.

Volatility expands again into midday

  • Shortly before noon, David reported an ES drop of more than 70 handles in under two minutes. He described the tape as too volatile to trade and later put the one-minute ATR peak near 16 points.

  • A member asked whether one of the room’s automated setups could catch those moves. David was skeptical. With the range expanding that quickly, he stepped away for lunch.

  • David cited a 222-point SPX range shortly after noon. Later, at about 2:53 p.m., a room member called out another test of 7220.

Late-session read

  • At about 3:52 p.m., David noted SPX down 1.80% and QQQ down 1.86% at the time of his posts. He characterized the late weakness as a tech selloff.

  • The shift from the early long lean to a brief balance at 7320 and then another surge in ATR shaped the room’s session. David’s decision to step aside was the clearest example of how he adjusted as the market sped up.